What Are the Most Underrated Movies? Part II (Ranked by Most Listed)

This companion list expands the scope to films that show strong but not yet dominant agreement as "underrated" within the ListChallenges community. It draws from the same 360 movie lists whose descriptions included underrated / under-rated / underated and required a minimum user base of 150, preserving broad participation over niche curation. This time, the focus is on films appearing on 8 to 10 different lists, a range that falls between minor recognition and emerging consensus—suggesting repeated validation without full critical mass. As with Part I (list 1), films are ranked from highest to lowest by total list appearances, revealing which titles consistently resonate with viewers as overlooked, even if they haven't yet crossed into widespread agreement. The result highlights the next tier of underrated films hovering just below clear consensus, often ripe for rediscovery or reappraisal.